People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I’ve lived in the Land O Lakes area For 23 years. This is the best pizza and Caesar salad EVER! The taste of the sauce is incredible and how they know the right amount of sauce, chef’s kiss, the taste of the cheese, and the bake of the pizza is more than five stars! It brought me back to Italy! The Caesar dressing, it is the best tasting dressing I’ve had in years! My daughter agrees! ”
“ Delicious!! We drove almost an hour to visit after reading other reviews and it did not disappoint!! Pizza was authentic and reminded me of back home in NY. Garlic knots were just okay. Dense and lacking flavor. The dining room had 5 or so tables, so it doesn’t have a restaurant feel if that’s what you’re looking for. But if you’re in the area, or an hour away and are looking for outstanding pizza, this is the place!! ”
“ Hands down one of the best Pizza Joints in the Tampa Bay Area. They make the sauce daily and use good quality ingredients, the owner Anthony is a great and friendly guy! I’ve been coming here for years and don’t plan on changing that. ”
“ I love their pizza. It is the closest to authentic New York pizza I have found. It is one of the few places I will still order out in these days of our crappy economy. My husband doesn't like pizza much, but he loves theirs. Thank you for years of delicious pizza here in Land O Lakes. ”
“ I went here for the first time today, was looking for good pizza. I just moved here 3 weeks ago.from VA and originally from Boston. Best pizza. Looking forward to the rest of the menu. Joe and Anthony are just great people. My new go to. Thank you ”
“ Bring friends & family & co Workers here Slate bottom crunchy flavorful pizzas...authentic Brooklyn Drop in/Call ahead/Order out/etc... Homemade CHEESECAKE to goSpecials Amazing customer service...momma taught em well! ”
“ Me and another momma with 3 kids and 2 babies called ahead and asked if we could have pizza in 15 minutes. The owner had it ready for us on time, and we were able to eat inside without making the kids wait. The pizza was delicious! The kids even commented about how great the pizza tasted. Next time we are close by, I’d definitely go back. ”
“ Absolutely five stars. The food at Pizza Suprema was delicious and fresh. Since moving down to Tampa from New York, this is the closest thing to real New York pizza that we have found. The staff was also fantastic. My son was wearing his Spider-Man watch and shirt, and they went out of their way to acknowledge him and make him feel like a million bucks. It made his day and ours. Great food, great service, and a place we will definitely keep coming back to. ”
Menu
Antipasto
Sausage Parmigiana
US$11.99Tiramisu
US$3.00Cannoli
US$3.00Potato & Eggs
US$6.99
About
Pizza Suprema
Welcome to Pizza Suprema, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Land O' Lakes, Florida. Located at 1905 Collier Pkwy, this pizzeria has garnered a reputation for serving some of the most mouthwatering and authentic Italian dishes in the Tampa Bay Area. With a phone call away at +1 813-909-4999, you can indulge in a culinary experience that transports your taste buds straight to Italy.
At Pizza Suprema, it's not just about the pizza—though their offerings stand out for sure. The rich, savory sauce is crafted daily, using only top-quality ingredients, ensuring every bite bursts with flavor. Customer reviews echo the sentiment of superb taste, with one recurring theme: the pizza here is reminiscent of authentic New York-style cuisine. Many patrons, including Carla Fairchild and Sandy Capps, rave about the deliciousness of the Caesar salad and the incredible crust, remarking how it strikes the perfect balance with the sauce and cheese.
The menu here is delightful and diverse, featuring not only pizza but also delicious pasta dishes like spaghetti and ziti with a choice of sauces—from classic tomato to rich vodka sauce, all starting as low as $7.99. For those craving protein, delectable dinners such as Eggplant Parmigiana and Meatballs & Peppers are available at $11.99. And let’s not forget dessert! Their cannoli and tiramisu, priced affordably at $3.00 each, offer just the right sweet touch to round off your meal.
While the intimate dining space may not provide the ambiance of a full-fledged restaurant, it's the quality of the food that keeps diners returning. Kassi Cusumano drove nearly an hour to relish their pizzas, declaring the trip worthwhile. This speaks volumes about the commitment to quality and flavor that owner Anthony brings to the table. Regulars like Peter Mestre appreciate not just the food but also the welcoming spirit of the establishment.
In a world where pizza can often be a quick, impersonal offering, Pizza Suprema stands as a warm reminder of what great pizza should be—crafted with love and authenticity. For those who appreciate the nuances of fine Italian cuisine without needing to travel far, Pizza Suprema is undoubtedly a top choice. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this is a culinary treasure worth exploring.
Book a table